If you have been watching Survivor: South Pacific, you may be forgiven for thinking she was single. After all, she told everyone she was single. But she lied! When Whitney headed off as a castaway, she not only had a boyfriend, or a fiancé. In fact, she was married! But she allegedly ruined that with her affair with fellow castaway Keith Tollefson.
Duncan (27) is a country singer and former Nashville Star finalist from Nashville. She secretly married Donny Fallgatter (32), the lead singer of the band KingBilly on August 1, 2010, shortly after they met at the CMA Music Festival in Nashville.
Duncan and Fallgatter reportedly announced their engagement to their friends and family just before Duncan left to film Survivor but they hid this from the show producers.
Fallgatter was allegedly “totally faithful while she was gone” while Duncan was away competing on the show. Not so Duncan, who is thought to have had an affair with Tollefson while a castaway, and told her husband about it before she returned.
Donny was understandably very upset. Whitney moved out of the marital home after she returned from Survivor. Shortly afterwards, Duncan and Tollefson were seen together around Nashville and she mentioned a boyfriend in multiple tweets.
A Tennessee judge heard Duncan and Fallgatter’s granted divorce filing on November 8. However, the divorce will not become final until signed papers are returned to the courthouse.
Could there be another Survivor wedding being planned? As for Whitney Duncan misrepresenting herself both to the producers of Survivor and her fellow contestants, including Tollefson, what do you think?